
Medical
Advantages of Circumcising a Newborn
The
prevalence of testicular cancer is considerably lower among circumcised
males than it is among uncircumcised males.
(New England Journal of Medicine 336; 1244-1245 (1997))
The prevalence of
urinary tract infections and their associated complications is significantly
lower among circumcised children than among uncircumcised children.
(Clinical Pediatrics 32; 130-134 (1993))
The prevalence of
sexually transmitted infectious diseases (STD) is lower among circumcised
males and their partners than among uncircumcised males.
(New England Journal of Medicine 322; 1308-1312(1990))
Possible
Complications Arising From Circumcision
Bleeding
- Extensive medical surveys show that it is highly improbable that
circumcision on the eighth day (or after) will cause profuse bleeding.
Cases of profuse bleeding documented in American medical journals
most likely resulted from the removal of the foreskin on the second
or third day of the child's life, as is common practice in the U.S
Infections
- In studies of hundreds of thousands of circumcised babies, the incidence
of circumcision-related infections was very low and could be avoided
by adhering to appropriate medical standards.
Anatomical
damage - Circumcision-caused injuries are highly uncommon since the
procedure is relatively simple and mohels (circumcision professionals)
use equipment which protects the organ. Anatomical damage is rare
when trained experienced professionals perform the circumcision procedure.
Halacha
considers the health of the newborn a supreme value. Therefore, it
is a mitzvah to take all necessary measures to avoid endangering his
health, including delaying the day of circumcision.
Medical
Developments and the Practice of Circumcision
Preventing
infection - Mohels today adhere to the same precautions as
are taken to prevent infection in similar medical procedures: sterilization
of the circumcision instruments, hand washing, specific bandaging
techniques and use of appropriate bandaging materials.
Minimizing
pain to the newborn during the circumcision - Various means are employed
today to reduce the pain of circumcision:
basic pain relief medication containing paracetimol (e.g. acamol,
dexamol, aldolor) in the appropriate dosage (1 cc/ 1 kg of the child's
weight, under guidance of a physician).
topical anesthetics.
proper instruction of parents regarding feeding of the baby before
and after the circumcision.
a drop of wine, grape juice, or sugar water sucked by the baby from
a gauze pad.
These
are all accepted and effective methods. It is doubtful whether the
practice of injecting anesthetic directly into the foreskin actually
reduces the pain of circumcision since the pain of the injection itself
is not necessarily any less than the pain of the circumcision.
Avoiding
bleeding - Though circumcision generally causes only minimal bleeding,
there are certain methods of circumcision which prevent any bleeding
whatsoever. A special clamping method is available which causes necrosis
of the foreskin, allowing for its bloodless removal. This method,
however, is not recommended as Jewish tradition requires drawing of
some blood during the brit milah. Additionally, while this
procedure may prevent bleeding, the necrosis is likely to increase
pain.
When
a circumcision is performed either by a certified mohel who
is familiar with the medical issues, or by a medical doctor who is
knowledgeable in Jewish law, and parents are properly prepared and
guided through the procedure, the child's family will feel confident
during the brit milah ceremony